One of the most damage-prone parts of your home is its roof. This component of your house is constantly being exposed to different extreme weather conditions, which can cause damage. Because of this, it can be expected homeowners to experience different types of roof damage, making them seek roof repair and replacement.

Between the two, it can be challenging to distinguish what your roof requires when damaged. Sometimes, a roof repair can be enough to fix the top of your home entirely, but other times, repairing the roof can be the best option. This article will discuss your best choice between roof replacement and roof repair.

Difference Between Roof Repair and Replacement

While the two options may seem similar, roof repair and replacement have some differences that make the other a better choice, depending on the condition of your roof. Below are some critical roof repair and replacement qualities that every homeowner should learn:

Roof Replacement

Roof replacement is the type of fix for your home that means explicitly replacing the old materials of most of your roof. This is usually done when the top of your house has been severely damaged. When too many parts have been damaged or destroyed, it can be not easy to salvage them, making replacing them more worthwhile.

Replacing your damaged roof can be costly, but it is important to note that having a brand-new roof is an investment that will last for a long time.

Roof Repair

The second option for fixing the top of your home is roof repair. This method means that replacing a considerable portion of your roof is unnecessary since tiny repairs can fix the damages. These repairs can include leaks, small holes, and other minor injuries that can easily be fixed.

Usually, if sealants and coatings can fix the damage you found on your roof, then roof repair can be the better choice, especially if your roof isn’t that old yet. Having a professional do the repairs is still the best option for minor roof fixes to ensure that it is done correctly.

Factors to Consider for Repairing or Replacing

With more understanding of the differences between roof repair and replacement, there are also factors that every homeowner should know to have better judgment when fixing their roofs. Here are some aspects of learning about when choosing between replacing or repairing your roof:

1. Type of Roof

One factor to consider when deciding between repairing or replacing is the type of roof you have. Certain types of roofs can last a while, such as slate roofs. This roof can last for almost a century, meaning it can be the best choice to repair slate roofs rather than replace them. The roof tiles can be easily replaced individually, so the repair labor is not troublesome.

On the other hand, roof replacement is the obvious option when the damage is from structural failures or severe water damage. 

2. Costs for Fixing Your Roof

An issue that should be fixed before deciding what course to take is learning about your roof expenses. Budget plays a huge role in determining which type of method is best for you. While replacing your roof can provide more long-term protection, this can also be more expensive than repairing.

Keeping this in mind, you should consider all these factors when budgeting for fixing your roof. For instance, while it can be cheaper to repair your roof, the damages may be big enough that they will keep coming back with just repairs. In that case, replacing your roof can be the more cost-efficient method.

3. The Roof’s Age

One of the biggest concerns when choosing a roof repair plan is the age of your roof. Before making a final decision, ask yourself when your roof was installed. Aside from the material used, the roof’s age can let you know whether it is reliable and robust enough. Some roofs last 10 to 15 years, so if your roof is still relatively new, having it repaired can be a better choice.

While repairing is a great way to save your roof from minor damages, this method still won’t increase the lifespan of your roof. As your roof ages, it is crucial to note that the need for replacing it grows, alongside whether or not it is severely damaged.


As a homeowner, you ensure that every inch of your home is sturdy and free from damage. Your roof is an integral part of your home that protects your household from damages that result from severe weather conditions. Big Bear Roofing offers quality repair and replacement for any homeowner when you require roofing services.